FLORIDACOUNTRY CLUB HOMES

21 Homes for Sale in Cutler Cay, Cutler Bay, FL

Cutler Bay

21 homes for sale

Homes in Cutler Cay range in price from approximately $775,000 to $2,200,000, range in square footage from around 2,700 to 4,700 sq ft and carry an average HOA fee around $500/month. The average list price per square foot is $297. Browse all 21 active Cutler Cay listings below, updated every 15 minutes.

Current Real Estate Statistics for Cutler Cay, Cutler Bay

Cutler Cay Active Listing Stats

as of Nov 13, 2026

Full Cutler Bay market report →

Active Listings

Avg Days on Market (Active)

68 days

Avg List $/Sqft

$297

Median List Price

$1.2M

Newest Homes for Sale in Cutler Cay, Cutler Bay

19343 SW 79th Ave, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

NEW - 3 DAYS AGO

$1,248,000

19343 SW 79th Ave, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

7645 SW 193rd Ln, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

7946 SW 195th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4.5 ba

3,399 ft²

7515 SW 191st St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

$1,045,000

7515 SW 191st St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4.5 ba

3,168 ft²

7770 SW 188th Terrace, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

$1,950,000

7770 SW 188th Terrace, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4 ba

3,945 ft²

19363 SW 79th Ave, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

$1,300,000

19363 SW 79th Ave, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4 ba

4,717 ft²

7846 SW 195th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

OPEN SUN 8:30 PM - 10 PM

$1,155,000

7846 SW 195th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4 ba

4,717 ft²

7876 SW 194th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

OPEN SUN 8 PM - 10 PM

$1,289,000

7876 SW 194th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

7956 SW 195th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

7512 SW 187th Street, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4.5 ba

3,982 ft²

19385 SW 79th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157 - photo 1 of 10

$910,000

19385 SW 79th Ct, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

7601 SW 187th St, Cutler Bay, FL, 33157

4.5 ba

3,982 ft²

Browse All 21 Cutler Bay Cutler Cay Homes for Sale

Sold-Home Market Trends

Cutler Bay Sold-Home Trends

Closed-sale trends for Cutler Bay, FL (median sold price & median days on market). Active listings below are current for-sale inventory.

Median Sold Price

$570,000

+1.8%

vs last month

+4.6% YoY

Median Days on Market (Sold)

47 days

Active Listings

272

Market Condition

Balanced Market

4.7 months of inventory

Computed from live MLS data via the Repliers API · MIAMI + RWorld (Board 175) and MIAMI MLS (Board 177) · updated daily

Median Sold Price

Median Days on Market (Sold)

* Chart and sold cards use closed sales over the last 12 months (median sold price / median days on market). Active-listing medians appear in the stats strip above.

Search Homes

Map Search

Browse by Type

Core Types

Single Family Homes Condos for Sale Townhomes for Sale

Lifestyle & Luxury

Luxury Homes Waterfront Homes Pool Homes New Construction Homes

Features

Gated Communities 55+ Communities 1 Story Homes